Restaurant News & Reviews

10 iconic Coast restaurants that are gone forever but will never be forgotten

Coast restaurants that are no more, and we miss them

Sun Herald readers told us about some of their favorite restaurants that have closed for one reason or another. May were closed by Hurricane Katrina, but they all had a favorite dish or just just a vibe that we miss.
Up Next
Sun Herald readers told us about some of their favorite restaurants that have closed for one reason or another. May were closed by Hurricane Katrina, but they all had a favorite dish or just just a vibe that we miss.

The Chicken Florentine lunch special at Rickey’s. The French dressing at Hugo’s. The hot yeast rolls from Ryan’s buffet.

Don’t forget about karaoke night at the Bombay Bicycle Club or the unusual dish served in 1928 at Annie’s in Pass Christian.

Hugos 1.JPG
Hugo’s in downtown Biloxi closed in 2003. It was the first place where French dressing was put on pizza. Back then, it was called “liquid cheese.” Sun Herald file

The Mississippi Gulf Coast has lost dozens of iconic restaurants and eateries over the decades. Some went out of business. Some were destroyed in Hurricane Katrina and never returned.

Or some just “retired” forever, much to their regular customers’ dismay.

South Mississippi residents reached out to the Sun Herald on Instagram and told us about their favorite memories from forgotten or closed restaurants. Here are the top 10.

Hugo’s

Hugos 2.JPG
Hugo’s Pizza Sun Herald file

The locally famous pizza shop that was on the coroner of West Division Street and Forrest Avenue closed for good in 2003, but it reigned supreme in the ’50s, ’60s and ’70s.

Hugo J. Rung Sr., a New York native stationed at Keesler Air Force Base, opened the stop in 1951. And it was there that Biloxi High students started putting “liquid cheese,” or French dressing, on their slices of pie.

That started a local trend across the Coast of putting French (or Catalina) on pizza, and it’s now available at most pizza places on the Coast.

“With pizza, it’s a Gulf Coast tradition,” Tony’s Brick Oven Pizza owner Tony Swigris told the Sun Herald in 2015.

Hugo’s New York-style pies and famous stuffed mushrooms are remembered fondly by Biloxians who were sad to see the restaurant go 15 years ago.

Tigre’s

Tigres 1.JPG
Tigre’s restaurant was at the intersection of Market and Second streets in Pass Christian. James Edward Bates Sun Herald/2002

Thomas Genin and Victor Pickich had to wait until they were 21 to get a liquor license to open their intimate fine-dining restaurant, pronounced tea-gray, in downtown Pass Christian.

Tigre’s was an instant hit and became known for culinary delights, including bacon-wrapped scallops and roasted filet mignon.

It opened in 2002 but was destroyed by Katrina in 2005. Four months later, the young business owners opened Tigre’s Supper Club in The Oaks, but that’s closed now, too.

In 2006, Pickich told the Sun Herald that he and Genin didn’t know what the future held.

Shaggy’s was named after a bar inside Tigre’s, and Genin now owns The Blind Tiger in several locations across the Gulf Coast, as well as Whiskey Prime in downtown Pass Christian.

Tigres 2.JPG
Southern Style BBQ Shrimp, left, and grilled rare Yellowfin tuna were among the entrees at Tigre’s in Pass Christian. James Edward Bates Sun Herald/2002

Mary Mahoney’s 24-hour cafe

Hurricane Katrina closed the only local cafe in Biloxi that served breakfast 24/7 (Waffle House not included) before Fillup with Billups opened in January on Caillavet.

The legendary Mary Mahoney’s Old French House survived three major hurricanes: Betsy (1965), Camille (1969) and Hurricane Katrina (2005), but Katrina took its beloved 24-hour cafe.

Locals could get breakfast, a quick po-boy or a cup of their world-famous gumbo any hour of the day or night and enjoy the beautiful courtyard situated in the middle of the bustling downtown Biloxi.

Vrazel’s

To many on the Coast, Vrazel’s Fine Dining was the place to enjoy a good meal and even better atmosphere in Gulfport.

“The best escargot on the Coast is at Vrazel’s. It’s served nice and hot, with garlic and butter,” one reader wrote to the Sun Herald in May 2005.

Katrina caused damage, but the restaurant came back. It closed for good in December 2012.

Chef William J. (Bill) Vrazel had planned to make a cookbook with recipes from his namesake restaurant, but he told the Sun Herald in July 2017 that it had to go on the back burner.

Vrazel often shares his recipes with the Sun Herald, including one for his famous Eggplant LaRosa.

Vrazel’s for story.JPG
Bill Vrazel, owner of Vrazel’s Fine Food Resturant, stands in what is left of the dining room at his business on U.S. 90 in Gulfport. Vrazel had several cargo containers from the Mississippi State Port wash up and into his building from the wind-driven storm surge of Hurricane Katrina. Katrina made landfall on the Mississippi Gulf Coast on Monday, August 29th, 2005. David Purdy Sun Herald/2005

Java Jean’s

Many Sun Herald readers miss having a New York-style bagel and hot sandwich from Java Jean’s, a popular deli that began as a coffee and bakery on Courthouse Road.

When 15th Street opened on the edge of downtown, owner Jean Baas moved her spot to the beachfront and shared the first floor of the building with Irish Coast Pub.

The building was heavily damaged in Katrina, and Salute Italian restaurant is now open where Java Jean’s once was.

In 2005, Baas told the Sun Herald she didn’t know if it was financially feasible to come back after the storm. She did not reopen.

Annie’s Restaurant

Annie’s 2.JPG
Annie’s Restaurant 120 W. Bayview in Pass Christian after Hurricane Katrina. John Fitzhugh Sun Herald/2005

Henderson Point lost one of its only businesses in 2005 when Katrina destroyed Annie’s, as it did most of the Pass Christian community that’s surrounded by water.

The restaurant had opened in 1928 and became popular for its unusual fried chicken and spaghetti dish, the Sun Herald reported in 2005.

The Italian-American fusion restaurant with Southern roots was a favorite among Coastians living in Bay St. Louis and Pass Christian.

Owner Annie Lutz and her family briefly opened a pop-up cafe after Katrina on Kiln-Delisle Road, but they closed it in December 2007. There was talk of the family opening Annie’s again in Henderson Point, but that never came to fruition.

“Henderson Point is home to us. Annie sure wants to get pack to the Point,” Niki Butterworth, Annie’s niece, told the Sun Herald in 2007.

Annie Lutz died in 2010.

Annie’s 1.JPG
Annie’s restaurant on Henderson Point in Pass Christian before Hurricane Katrina destroyed it. Tammy Smith Sun Herald/file/2005

Bombay Bicycle Club

Bombay Bicycle Club 2.JPG
Tammy Beaugez of Gulfport struts her stuff during the ”Dance like Elaine” contest at the Bombay Bicycle Club in Biloxi in 1998. The Seinfeld event was sponsored by Live ’95 radio station and led up to the viewing of the final episode of the show. Beaugez was the hands down winner of the contest. Vernon Matthews Sun Herald/file/1998

The BBC was mainly a bar, but a lot of Sun Herald readers remember the beachfront spot at the coroner of U.S. 90 and Reynoir Street for its elevated bar food and generous portioned appetizers.

The theme was tropical safari, and there was a drink special and appetizer special at the bar every single night from 4 p.m. to close.

There was also happy hour specials and ladies night when drinks were 99 cents.

The Sun Herald covered a “Dance Like Elaine” event at the BBC in 1998. The contest paid homage to Elaine Benes of “Seinfeld.”

In 2001, a Sun Herald food critic said the spinach dip was delicious and the bar had the best Bloody Mary on the Coast. It came with stuffed olives and spicy green beans.

Other BBC favorites were the wings, nachos and quesadillas. Oh, and the karaoke.

The BBC was destroyed by Katrina and was never rebuilt.

Marguerite’s Italian Village

If this family-friendly restaurant was anything, it was consistent.

In 2003, several diners told the Sun Herald that the food and service were always excellent.

“We’ve added maybe three or for things in the last 28 years,” owner/operator Liz O’Cain said in 2003. “One of our greatest compliments is when someone comes in that hasn’t been here for 15 years and says, ‘Oh, it tastes just like it did 15 years ago.’ To me, that’s the highest compliment because we go for consistency in our food.’”

The restaurant’s most popular dish was the Marguerite Special, Gulf shrimp and mushrooms prepared in a seasoned garlic butter over spaghetti, which cost $14.95.

Marguerite’s opened in 1975 and closed after it was heavily damaged in Hurricane Katrina.

Marguerite’s.JPG
Dining room manager Debbie Cooper, an employee of Marguerite’s Italian Village in Pascagoula for 19 years, shows the Marguerite Special with sauteed gulf shrimp and seasoned mushrooms and Eggplant Lamberto, which is stuffed with gulf shrimp and Italian bread dressing, seasonings and topped with Mornay sauce and mushrooms. James Edward Bates Sun Herald/file

Bay City Grill

The alfredo sauce couldn’t be beat.

The atmosphere was coastal meets New Orleans and the menu matched the decor.

Bay City Grill was a favorite in the Depot District near downtown.

While the restaurant never returned after Katrina, locals can still get their popular spinach and artichoke spring rolls at Sea Level in Pass Christian.

Bay City Grill.JPG
Friends of the Animal Shelter in Hancock County held a benefit calendar signing at Bay City Grill in Bay St. Louis in 2004. James Edward Bates Sun Herald file

Alberti’s Italian

First it was Katrina. Then the economy. And the 2010 BP oil spill was the final straw for Alberti’s fine dining.

The Albertis, Moe and Yvonne, began their culinary venture in the 1960s when they opened Moe’s New York Pizza on Pass Road, just outside Keesler Gate 7. It was in instant hit, the Albertis told the Sun Herald in 2010.

They closed the pizza shop and opened Alberti’s Italian on U.S. 90 and were known for the massive gorilla that adorned the beachfront sign.

Oh, and don’t forget about the elevated Italian fare from family recipes, including manicotti and toasted ravioli.

Yvonne Alberti’s rum cake and bread pudding were favorites among locals, the Sun Herald reported.

The Albertis (and their gorilla) moved to Ocean Springs after Katrina leveled the Biloxi location. They closed for good in June 2010.

“I will miss the people, Yvonne Alberti said. “But it’s time to reitre. The economy, Katrina and this oil is a lot to handle right now.”

Alberti’s 1.JPG
A souvenir shop and restaurant had two fixtures on U.S. 90 in Biloxi. The alligator is for the souvenir shop and the gorilla for Alberti’s Italian Restaurant. Tim Isbell Sun Herald/file/2003

Honorable mention

Several Sun Herald Instagram followers said they missed three chain restaurants that lined U.S. 90 on the Gulfport-Biloxi line: Olive Garden, Red Lobster and Landry’s seafood.

Bombay Bicycle Club 1.JPG
Patrons of Bombay Bicycle Club joke together during a late afternoon break. Sean Loftin Sun Herald/file

Justin Mitchell; 228-604-0705; @JustinMitchell_
  Comments